查詢結果分析
來源資料
頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 法國第五共和與臺灣當前憲政體制之比較:以憲政選擇與憲政結構為中心=Comparing the Constitutional System in the French Fifth Republic and the ROC: Focusing on Constitutional Choice and Structure |
---|---|
作 者 | 蘇子喬; | 書刊名 | 美歐季刊 |
卷 期 | 13:4=136 民88.冬 |
頁 次 | 頁465-515 |
分類號 | 576.8942 |
關鍵詞 | 法國第五共和; 半總統制; 雙首長制; 行政權雙軌制; 總理總統制; 總統議會制; The French Fifth Republic; Semi-presidentialism; System of dual executives; Alternating; Premier-presidentialism; President-parliamentarism; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 憲政體制的研究可以區分為憲政選擇、憲政結構與憲政影警等三個研究領域。 本文以憲政選擇與憲政結構為中心,比較法國第五共和與臺灣當前的憲政體制。在憲政選擇 方面,法國第五共和與我國當前憲政體制的形成過程有相當多的相似之處。這兩個憲政體制 都是總統制和內閣制折衝的產物;總統的權力在憲政發展過程中皆不斷擴大;並且兩者都有 試圖讓行政部門擺脫國會干預的思維方式;另外,我們也可以看到外部因素與政治強人對這 兩個憲政體制形塑的關鍵影響。在憲政結構方面,本文首先討論學界對於法國第五共和憲政 運作模式的以往觀點做了若干修正。法國第五共和憲政體制的各種定位方式,並對於接下來 以我國當前憲政論辯為切入點,歸納出三個憲政重點。這三個爭點分別是總統的解散國會權 、總統對行政院長的免職權,以及總統的國安大政決定權,而後以這三個爭點為基礎,進一 步建立我國未來憲政定位走向的架構。經由法國與我國當前憲政結構的排比,我們可以發現 ,儘管我國當前憲制多處參考法國第五共和的憲政架構,但由於許多關鍵爭點尚未得到澄清 ,因此在我國未來的憲政定位走向上,並不必然走向法國第五共和這種較順暢的憲政運作模 式,而有可能往其他的半總統制的次類型發展。 |
英文摘要 | The studies of constitutional system can be divided into three areas: constitutional choice, constitutional structure, and constitutional impact. This paper focuses on the first two areas to compare the constitutional system in the French Fifth Republic and the Republic of China. In the area of constitutional choice, many similarities can be found in the shaping process of the two constitutional systems. In the area of constitutional structure, this paper tries to revise the narrative about the constitutional system of France through an examination of the current issues of typology of the French system. We will then try to clarify the system of the central government of the Republic of China that was clouded by current debates over the constitution. In this way, three key points of constitutional debates can be found: (l) whether the President can take the initiative to dissolve the Legislative Yuan; (2) whether the President can single-handedly remove the Premier, and (3) whether the President can unilaterally determine major policies for national security. In spite of substantial borrowing from the French constitution, the constitution developed in the Republic of China is not bound to be like the constitutional system of France, which is considered the smoothest case in all kinds of semi-presidential systems, because of the vagueness in these three key points of constitutional debates. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。