頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 法規範的三個社會基礎:論Hermann Heller的法概念論=The Three Foundations of Legal Norm: On Hermann Heller's Concept of Law |
---|---|
作 者 | 鍾芳樺; | 書刊名 | 中原財經法學 |
卷 期 | 15 民94.12 |
頁 次 | 頁1-76 |
分類號 | 580.1 |
關鍵詞 | 實證法語句; 倫理性法原則; 綜合論; 常態性; 規範性; 應然與實然; 正當性; Positive legal sentences; Ethical fundamental principles of law; Syncretism; Normality; Normativity; Is and ought; Legitimacy; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 本文探討德國威瑪時期重要的法學者Hermann Heller(西元一八九一年至一九三三年)的法概念論。在指出Heller 法概念論的首要問題是如何解釋「法既是實然,又是應然」的問題後,本文進而分析Heller 如何用國家(作為社群權威)、作為常態性的行為規則、以及這些規則中被正面積極評價的倫理性法原則這三個社會現象之間的辯證關係來回答此一問題。Heller 指出,法的內容必須要來自經由社會文化演進形成之倫理性法原則;而這個倫理性法原則必須通過國家權力才能獲得法適用上必須的明確性與法安定性。另一方面,國家行為也必須基於具體化倫理性法原則才能獲得證立。Heller 認為,這個具體化的過程必須建立在社會民主之上。以這樣的思考方式,Heller 的理論指出了如何協調多元社會與國家統一性的需求,並在另一方面證立了民主法治國的必要性。 |
英文摘要 | This article analyzes the concept of law in legal and state theory of the famous Germany jurist Hermann Heller (1891-1933). In his theory of concept of law he wants to solute the antinomy of Is (Sein) and Ought (Sollen) in traditional legal philosophy and legal theory. In his points of view, the law in the one hand is normative (Sollen), and in the other hand factual (Sein). The positivity and validity of legal norms must come form the connection of Is and Ought (this point of view is so-called “Syncretism”). So Heller disapproves of Kelsen’s pure theory of law (Reine Rechtslehre), because it neglects the importance of rightness of the content of legal norms, and the factual background of legal norms. Heller also criticizes Carl Schmitt’s decisinism (Dezisionismus), because it reduces the law to pure political power. Heller points out that law comes from the Gestalt of the social process of mankind, and bases on the dialects of three social phenomenon: state (as authority in the community), regularity of social actions (as Normality), and ethical fundamental principles of law. The ethical fundamental principles of law play the central role in Heller’s theory of law. He wants to use this conception to overcome the distinction of Is and Ought, and to point out the criterion of legitimacy of State. These principles come from the Normality of human actions, which is recognized as the moral value in a Society or part of human nature. The evolution of social culture will change the content of these principles. The State must concrete these ethical fundamental principles of law as positive legal sentences. This Process of concretion must carry out in parliamentary procedure and social democracy. By this theory of law, Heller justifies necessity of democratic rule of law (Rechtsstaat) in a plural society. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。