頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 「犯罪被害人保護法」之補償規定及其實務分析=The Compensatory Provisions of "Criminal Victims Protection Act" and Its Cases Analysis |
---|---|
作 者 | 鍾秉正; | 書刊名 | 臺北大學法學論叢 |
卷 期 | 52 2003.06[民92.06] |
頁 次 | 頁27-70 |
分類號 | 587.7 |
關鍵詞 | 犯罪被害人保護法; 國家責任; 社會補償; 社會法; 犯罪被害補償; 社會保險; The Criminal Victims Compensation Act; State responsibility; Social compensation; Social law; Criminal victims' compensation; Social insurance; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 「犯罪被害人保護法」即為「犯罪被害人補償法」。此一制度之建立使得國家由打擊與防治犯罪之「干涉者」,轉為補償與保護犯罪被害之「給付者」。惟其立意雖佳,但由於相關規定之闕漏,反而易淪為「畫餅充飢」。該法自民國87年實施之後,不僅檢察機關任務加重,對於犯罪被害人之保護亦有不足。筆者乃以「社會法」之觀點針對該制度提出批評與建議。 有關犯罪被害補償規定之探討與實務分析,本文之寫作順序如下: 第一階段先從傳統公法學的觀點來分析,設法找出我國建立犯罪被害補償制度之憲法依據。再則介紹行政法學上對於國家責任之理論,比較國內學者對於「社會補償」在行政損失補償法上之定位。第二階段則自「社會法」之角度出發,首先介紹社會法之學理體系,而後為犯罪被害補償於社會補償制度中找尋定位。第三階段則介紹我國現行犯罪被害補償規定以及實務上之經驗,再以社會法之觀點分析實務上所面臨的問題並提出建議。 |
英文摘要 | “The Criminal Victims Protection Act” is tantamount to a “criminal victims’ compensation act.” The establishment of such a compensatory system made the state’s role turning from an “interferor” - for attacking and preventing crime, to a “payor”- for compensating and protecting victims. A1though the Act was well intended, yet, due to lack of auxiliary measures, it turned out to be a piece of legislation feeding on illusions. Since its enactment is 1998, the workload of prosecutors’ offices has increased, yet the protection for criminal victims is still deficient. The author attempts to criticize this compensatory system and make numerous suggestions from the standpoint of “social law.” This article shall bring out the discussion and cases analysis for the compensatory provisions of criminal victims in the following orders: First, I shall analyze said Act from the viewpoint of traditional public law, try to find a constitutional basis for it. Then, I shall introduce the theory of state responsibility in the administrative law, and compare various scholars’ propositions for “social compensation” in administrative damages. Second, I shall set out from the standpoint of “social law”, introduces briefly relevant social law theory, and then try to find the position for criminal victims’ compensation in the entire social compensation system. Third, I shal1 introduce current provisions of the Criminal Victims Compensation Act, discuss experience of several real cases, analyze the issues of these cases, and make suggestions from the viewpoint of social law. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。