頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 批判性法律研究之評析(上)=On Critical Legal Studies (1) |
---|---|
作 者 | 洪鎌德; | 書刊名 | 哲學與文化 |
卷 期 | 29:1=332 2002.01[民91.01] |
頁 次 | 頁1-15+93 |
分類號 | 580.1 |
關鍵詞 | 批判性法律研究; 自由派法律學說; 法律現實主義; 公家的與私人個; 個人主義對抗利他主義; 權力知識之關聯; 同居契約; 女性主義; 少數民族; 意識型態; CLS; The critics; Liberal legalism; Legal realism; The public and private; Individualism vs. altruism; Power knowledge; The cohabitation contract; Feminism; Minorities; Ideology; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 本為指出批判性法律社會學崛起於1970年代末,而成為過卻20年來美國傳統法學思潮之一大逆流。它所要抨擊的為資本主義體制之下,競爭性的市場經濟與維護個人自由人權的政治體制。特別是英美普通法強調司法中契約之自由、自主,從而忘卻契約記包含私人的性質,更含有公家干涉的特徵。批判性法 律研究,在指摘英美法系中司法之前後矛盾,不確定性,與缺法穩定性,也反駁形式主義、主張法律在排難解分中之逐漸邊緣化。要之,主流派的自由法學說乃是一種意識型態,旨在法與正當化資本主義的體制。文中舉出法律形式與法律實質之結合關係,契約學說、特別是未婚同居的契約學說之種種內在矛盾,都顯示現行法律之重大缺陷。最後以女性主義與少數民族對批判性法律研究之批評,從新檢討與估量此一北美法學思潮之得失。 |
英文摘要 | This article deals with the basic tenets and methodologies of Critical Legal Studies (CLS), which have had an enormous influence on legal scholarship during the last two and a half decades in the Anglo-Saxon countries. The CLS scholars, or labeled as the Critics, have produced varied writings in order to criticize the dominant liberal legal doctrine as an ideology of free-market economy and liberal democratic politics. According to the Critics, the doctrine of liberal legalism is full of contradictions and inconsistencies. The CLS seek to transform that ideology along with the oppressive and exploitative social institutions and human associations that it engenders. Through the processes of “trashing” as a technique, the Critics try to demystify and delegitimate the existing capitalist political, economic and social order propounded by liberal legalism. Having discussed the contradictions between formal and substantive legal issues of American private law as well as the inconsistencies inherent in the traditional contract doctrine, the essay finally turns to the critique of Critical Legal Studies leveled by feminism and minorities. In conclusion, the treatise evaluates the merits and deficiencies of this recent intellectual trend of American legal scholarship. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。