查詢結果分析
來源資料
頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 司法精神鑑定結果與法庭判決之比較=Results of Forensic Psychiatric Evaluation and the Court Sentencing |
---|---|
作 者 | 何海; 莊明敏; 林信男; 林憲; | 書刊名 | 臺灣精神醫學 |
卷 期 | 11:3 1997.09[民86.09] |
頁 次 | 頁54-60 |
分類號 | 586.669 |
關鍵詞 | 司法精神鑑定; 心神喪失; 精神耗弱; Forensic psychiatric evaluation; Insanity defense; Decreased criminal responsibility; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 目的︰比較精神鑑定中醫師之結論與法庭判決結果之一致率。方法︰選取民國81至83年3年間於省立桃園療養院實施精神鑑定之個案,索取法院判決書與鑑定報告書分析比較。結果︰179例樣本中,民事案件95例,其中最多為禁治產宣告共90例(94.7%),診斷以智能不足最多共38例(40.0%);刑事案件84例,其中竊盜罪最多共23例(27.4%),診斷以精神分裂症最多共29例(34.5%)。一致率︰民事案件為100%,刑事案件為93.6%。結論︰結果呈現極高的一致率,顯示可能隨著社會之演進,對精神與心理專業的需求與素質要求亦日趨升高,精神科醫師除努力加強專業、發展具鑑定特異性的評估技巧、評量工具外,充實法律知識、加強與法界專業人士之溝通與合作亦屬必需。研究的結果應可作為醫師、法官重要的參考資料,對於醫師所關注之精神病人權益、法官所關注社會安全與正義之維護提供了溝通的切入點;從這些資料可推演出來的「刑責能力判定準則」,將更具有參考價值。未來相關研究應加入法官意見之訪查,以反映法界觀點。 |
英文摘要 | Objective: Study of the consistency rate between the psychiatrist's judgment and the court sentences in forensic psychiatric evaluation (FPE). Methods: Analysis of the 179 FPE case records of a provincial psychiatric hospital over a 3-year period and court sentences of these cases. Results: These were 95 civil cases and 84 criminal cases. Among civil cases, 40.0% were mental retardation, 94.7% for interdiction. Among criminal cases, 34.5% were schizophrenia, 27.4% for larceny. Consistency rates between the psychiatrist's judgment and court sentences were 100% for civil cases and 93.6% for criminal cases. Conclusion: the results of the study provide an FPE reference for psychiatrists and data for judges which may be used to establish a starting point for communication about patients' rights and social safety which are joint concerns of both psychiatrists and judges as well as society as a whole. These results may also be useful in developing a criteria for criminal responsibility. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。