頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 技職校院中評鑑倫理兩難之探析=An Exploration on Ethical Dilemma in Technological and Vocational School Evaluation Practice |
---|---|
作 者 | 曾淑惠; | 書刊名 | 教育研究與發展期刊 |
卷 期 | 5:3 2009.09[民98.09] |
頁 次 | 頁209-239 |
專 輯 | 教育政策與制度 |
分類號 | 524.675 |
關鍵詞 | 評鑑倫理; 倫理兩難; 技職校院; Evaluation ethic; Ethical dilemma; Technological and vocational school; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 國內技職校院評鑑實務直至1998年職校評鑑時,才開始規範「訪評委員倫理準則」。然而評鑑倫理並非只應用於規範評鑑委員,受評單位在評鑑倫理的議題中仍應扮演重要角色。準此,本研究旨在探討技職校院因應評鑑所遭遇倫理兩難的情境,並界定處理倫理兩難的倫理守則。為達研究目的,本研究訪談30位技職校院評鑑關係人,並邀請五位評鑑理論與實務專家及32位德懷術專家進行意見調查以界定倫理議題,最後獲致以下結論:一、技職校院在因應評鑑時主要遭遇14項倫理兩難情境,其中受評者不願說出真實情形、運用與評鑑委員的人際關係影響評鑑結果以及評鑑結果的運用等問題受訪者有較深刻的感受。二、技職校院避免遭遇評鑑倫理兩難問題的倫理守則共可分為4面向共13項。 |
英文摘要 | There were no ethic guidelines for evaluators until the vocational high schools evaluation in 1998. But, evaluator is not the only one who should take the responsibility to obey the ethic codes. The object of evaluation should fulfill its own obligation too. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to discuss the ethic dilemma situation in technological and vocational school evaluation. Semi-structured interview and opinion survey were used in order to collect information, which 30 stakeholders were interviewed and another 5 scholar and 32 delphi expert were involved in opinion survey. The main conclusions of this study are as follows: 1. There are 14 ethical dilemma situations of school evaluation. The major problems occurred in the situations such as: the school member do not tell the truth, the staff tried to influence evaluators and want to get better grades, and how to use the evaluation results. 2. The ethic guidelines which avoid the ethical dilemma situations occurring in technological and vocational school evaluation can be divided into 4 dimensions and 13 items. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。