頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 教師訴諸行政訴訟案件之研究--1997~2005年=An Inquiry Administrative Lawsuits Charged by Teachers--from 1997 to 2005 |
---|---|
作 者 | 許禎元; | 書刊名 | 師大政治論叢 |
卷 期 | 5 民94.08 |
頁 次 | 頁71-101 |
分類號 | 588.16 |
關鍵詞 | 教師法; 教師行政訴訟; 教師申訴; Teacher's law; Administrative lawsuits by teachers; Faculty grievance; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 1980年代特別權力關係理論的崩解,大法官歷次釋憲案僅鬆脫了人民居於特定身份者,得不受特別權利關係的拘束,在不服行政主體的作為處分時,得提起訴願及行政訴訟,使其司法救濟地位與一般人民無異。1995年教師法頒布施行,明訂教師對主管教育行政機關或學校有關其個人之措施,認為違法或不當,得向各級教師申訴評議委員會提出申訴,教師爰對與學校公法上的爭執事件得提起訴訟。然則,教師與學校間係屬於契約僱傭關係,各級政府或怠於與教師會議決,或單方面決定聘約準則,聘約所涉及教師權利義務者,概係學校居於強勢地位所決定,教師既無從自由選擇,祇能被動接受學校單方安排,難免叢生怨言。總計1997年至2005年6月間,教師訴諸行政訴訟計有212案,僅約占所轄法院件數的1%,顯見教師訴諸行政訴訟案件並不多。而在全部212件系爭中,教師勝訴者僅28件(13.2%),敗訴者則有145件(68.4%),程序駁回者有35件(16.5%),而經最高行政法院發回更審者4件(1.9%)。 |
英文摘要 | Since 1980, the theory of Das besonderes Gewaltverhaltnis fade out and thus the public employees as well as teachers were allowed to bring forth grievance and administrative proceeding while dissatisfied with the unitary action of authority. The Teacher's law was enacted in 1995 stipulate that the employment relationship between teachers and schools was based on contracts providing bilateral rights and obligations. However' the actual practice disclosed the reciprocal inequality of treatment and teachers were forced to obey authority's compulsory regulations with no choice. The teachers can't help but to accept it with depression in mind. Some refused to obey the treatment tried to initiate a case can only find the barricade to charge by themselves. Totally calculated, there were only 212 cases of administrative lawsuit charged by teachers from 1997 to June of 2005. The number 212 which can only explain one percentage of the whole cases of lawsuit of the belonged courts didn't mean anything. Among these cases of administrative lawsuit charged by teachers' only 28(13.2%)cases won, 145(68.4%)cases lose, 35(16.5%)cases were procedurally rebutted, and 4(1.9%)cases were reheard. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。