頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 徘徊在非常上訴的十字路口--評張志文盜匪案之非常上訴及相關判決=Hesitating on a Crossroads of Extraordinary Appeal--Comment on the Extraordinary Appeal of Zhang-robbery-case and Its Relevant Judgments |
---|---|
作 者 | 林鈺雄; | 書刊名 | 政大法學評論 |
卷 期 | 83 2005.02[民94.02] |
頁 次 | 頁311-364 |
分類號 | 587.847 |
關鍵詞 | 間接故意; 容任理論; 非常上訴; 審判違背法令; Indirect intention; Theory of toleration; Extraordinary appeal; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 本文從張志文盜匪案出發,檢討實體法的間接故意理論,以及程序法的非常上訴之相關問題。就實體法言,本案案例事實其實已經挑戰了間接故意的概念,尤其是容任理論,本文從德國一則相關案例 (皮帶案) 出發,比較相關理論之發展與出路。就程序法言,我國刑事訴訟法非常上訴制度的設計瑕疵及實務發展的弊端,剛好在本案表現無遺,本文認為判斷非常上訴是否及於被告,應該回歸立法擬制的明確基準,並具體提出判斷之依據。 |
英文摘要 | We set out from the Zhang-robbery-case to review the theory of indirect intention in positive law, extraordinary appeal in procedural law and its relevant problems. For positive law, this case has in fact challenged the notion of indirect intention, especially the theory of toleration. We start from a relevant case (case of leather belt/Lederrie- menfall) in Germany and compare the development and outlet of relevant theories. For procedural law, the weakness of design for the extraordinary appeal system in our criminal procedural law and defect of development in practice exactly show in the case. Whether the effect of extraordinary appeal influences an accused should return to a clear and definite criteria which legislation draws up and concretely offer a judging base. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。