查詢結果分析
來源資料
頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 我國政黨初選制度的效應評估=Evaluation of the Effects of Party Primary System in Taiwan |
---|---|
作 者 | 吳重禮; | 書刊名 | 國立中正大學學報 |
卷 期 | 10:1(社會科學分冊) 民88.12 |
頁 次 | 頁93-130 |
分類號 | 576.86 |
關鍵詞 | 政黨; 初選制度; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 我國朝野三個主要政黨皆曾採行過初選制度。然而,初選的實施引發相當的爭議,批評之理由可歸納為:其一,初選引發派系嚴重反彈;其二,黨員結構與選民結構的差異,弱化政黨競爭能力;其三,初選競爭破壞黨內團結;其四,初選鼓勵黑金充斥等惡質化選風;其五,參選人須經兩次競爭,未戰先竭;其六,現行民意代表選舉制度,並不適合初選制度;其七,開放式初選易遭跨黨動員。反對初選的另一項理由是基於國情不同的考量。再者,為改革初選的種種問題,民進黨內提出各項芻議,譬如廢除或者降低黨費以杜絕人頭黨員及防範初選賄選,廢除或大幅減少初選的比重,完全或加重民調比例以決定提名人選等。經由分析檢證相關資料,本文以為,初選問題的癥結並不在於制度之缺漏,部份黨務幹部無法恪守「選務中立」的原則,意圖壟斷候選人提名之權,才是造成初選弊端的主因。瞭解提名制度的相關模型以及我國政黨初選制度的爭議,本文認為,隨著民主化的發展,社會利益愈趨多元,任何政黨欲求長存賡續發展,必須建立公允的提名制度。 |
英文摘要 | In the past decade, three major political parties in Taiwan had adopted the party primary system. Nevertheless, the use of the party primary has been controversial, critics charging it with some flaws: intra-party factions hindered the nominated candidates by supporting opposition candidates in general elections; those who won in primary elections proved not necessarily electable in general elections, since party identifiers were different from the electorate; it frequently led to sharper power struggles; it worsened the illegal practice of violence and vote-buying; aspirants underwent two campaigns for one election, spending energy and money twice; the electoral system for the election of representatives has an adverse effect on the primary system; the open primary allowed "crossing-over" by voters from the opposition political parties Taiwan's political climate seemed inapt for the practice of U.S. style primary election system. Debating points aside, the Democratic Progressive Party recent years planed some reform proposals, e.g., to abolish or reduce dues-paying for party memberships, to replace the primary with "public opinion survey." By analyzing relevant data, I argue that the core problem of the party primary was its lack of fairness because party cadres tried to monopolize the candidate selection and thus failed to remain neutral. Throughout this essay and in the conclusion, I note that any political party appears likely to open its candidate selection practice in an attempt to continue its political dominance. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。