查詢結果分析
來源資料
頁籤選單縮合
題 名 | 司法院大法官有關「權力分立原則」解釋之研析(上):總體分析=A Critical Review of the Council of Grawl Justice Interpretations on the Separation-of-Powers Doctrine in the Constitution of the Republic of China on Taiwan |
---|---|
作 者 | 湯德宗; | 書刊名 | 政大法學評論 |
卷 期 | 54 1995.12[民84.12] |
頁 次 | 頁19-60 |
分類號 | 572.13 |
關鍵詞 | 權力分立; 權力分立原則; 分權與制衡; 大法官解釋; 司法審查; |
語 文 | 中文(Chinese) |
中文摘要 | 本文旨在就司法院大法官歷來(自釋字第一號解釋至釋字第三七四號解釋)所屬有關「權力分立原則」諸解釋,進行通盤分析與評論。全文分為五章。第一章(前言)說明研究之動機、目的與方法。第二章簡述「權力分立原則」理論,作為本文以下解釋案分類及評析之基礎。第三章分析大法官有關「權力分立原則」解釋案之統計資料,期窺悉「權力分立原則」解釋案之總體發展趨勢。第四章將五十六件人法官有關「權力分立原則」之解釋,依其發揮之主要作用,分成「水平分權」、「垂直分權」、「權力相互制衡」、「權力相互尊重」及「憲政體制之維 繫」等五大類十六小類逐案進行評析。第五章 (結論) 總結研究發現。 本文附件計有: 表一(大法官有關「權力分立原則」解釋案要旨一覽表) 表二(大法官有關「權力分立原則」解釋案件比重分析) 表三(大法官解釋案聲請人類別分析) 表四(大法官有關「權力分立原則」解釋案機關聲請人分析) 圖一(「權力分立原則」解釋案佔「憲法解釋案」比重變化圖) 圖二(「權力分立原則」解釋案佔「公布解釋案」比重變化圖) 圖三(美國憲法中的三權分立與制衡:“野心必須用野心加以對抗”) 圖四(我國憲法中的五權分立與制衡:“五權分治平等相維”) |
英文摘要 | This paper provides the most comprehensive review to date of the interpretations ( decisions ) by the Council of Grand Justices on the Separation - of Powers Doctrine under the constitution of the Republic of China on Taiwan, which adopts a unique separation of powers among five branches. Section I explains the motives of writing, the goals to be achieved, and the methods used. Section I] investigates the theoretical underpinnings of the Doctrine to form a basis for the critical review of the interpretations. Section Ill analyzes the statistics about the interpretations on the Doctrine to see the tendency of development and the impact of the enactment of the 1 958 Statute Governing the Council of Grand Justices on the practice of constitutional adjudications. Section IV reviews the fifty- six interpretations on the Doctrine case by case under five categories, i.e., horizontal separation of powers, vertical separation of powers, checks and balances among branches, mutual respects among branches, and efforts in mointaining of constitutional democracy. Section V summarizes the findings and suggestions. The appendix includes four tables and four figures. |
本系統中英文摘要資訊取自各篇刊載內容。