頁籤選單縮合
題名 | 從「法與政治的二元對立」論Carl Schmitt對當代德國憲法學的影響=The Influence of Carl Schmitt on Contemporary German Constitutional Jurisprudence in Light of the Dichotomy of Law and Politics |
---|---|
作者 | 黃舒芃; Hwang, Shu-perng; |
期刊 | 輔仁法學 |
出版日期 | 20191200 |
卷期 | 58 2019.12[民108.12] |
頁次 | 頁39-97 |
分類號 | 581.43 |
語文 | chi |
關鍵詞 | 德國憲法學; 威瑪共和; 基本法秩序; 法與政治二元論; 政治法治化; 政治形成空間; 憲法同一性; German constitutional jurisprudence; Weimar Republic; Constitutional order of German basic law; Dichotomy of law and politics; Juridification of politics; Verrechtlichung der politik; Political discretion; Politischer gestaltungsspielraum; Constitutional identity; |
中文摘要 | 在德國憲法學發展史上,Carl Schmitt的學說無疑佔有舉足輕重的地位。他不但是威瑪共和時期公法學界的代表性人物,在國際上更是法政學界長久以來十分熱門的研究對象。然而,有鑑於Schmitt明確支持納粹政權的意識形態立場,當代德國憲法學界的主流,並不積極耙梳Schmitt的憲法理論與當代德國憲法學發展取向的關連。本文的主要目的,在於透過對戰後至今德國憲法學發展軌跡的觀察與分析,指出當代德國憲法學究竟如何、或者在何等意義上,反映了Schmitt的思想特質,而如此之反映又預示了什麼樣的發展前景。為了清楚凸顯Schmitt對當代發展之影響具有一定程度的普遍性,而且源遠流長,本文將選擇鎖定在二次戰後德國憲法學界主流見解對「法」與「政治」二者關係的看待方式上,試圖透過對主流見解所持「法與政治二元論」之基本立場,以及這個基本立場在不同發展階段各種具體呈現方式的觀察,指出主流見解如何繼承了Schmitt對「法」與「政治」二者關係的看法,又如何因此而讓Schmitt的憲法理論繼續伴隨著基本法秩序的發展,歷久彌新。 |
英文摘要 | Carl Schmitt's constitutional thought has undoubtedly played a decisive role for the development of German constitutional jurisprudence. However, due to his ideological support for the Nazi regime, the German mainstream has not paid much attention on the intellectual connection between Schmitt's constitutional theory and the mainstream approach of the development of German constitutional law since World War II. Through observing and analyzing the postwar developments of German constitutional law in theory and practice, this article aims to illustrate how the contemporary German constitutional jurisprudence has inherited the characteristics of Schmitt's constitutional thoughts, and what the legacy of Schmitt indicates. In particular, it attempts to show how and in what sense the mainstream view on the dichotomy of law and politics has reflected Schmitt's perspective on the relationship between law and politics, and consequently, how Schmitt's unique approach to constitutional law continues to influence the development of German constitutional theory and jurisprudence. |
本系統之摘要資訊系依該期刊論文摘要之資訊為主。